- Charles Francis Adams, Jr., president of the Union Pacific Railroad and the American Historical Association
- Henry Adams, author
- Edward Atkinson, entrepreneur and business executive
- Charles William Eliot, President of Harvard University
- E. L. Godkin, editor of The Nation
- Thomas Nast, political cartoonist
- Carl Schurz, former Senator from Missouri and Secretary of the Interior, editor of the Saturday Evening Post
- Moorfield Storey, lawyer and NAACP president from 1909–1915
- William Graham Sumner, social scientist, Yale University
- Horace White, editor of the Chicago Tribune
- And in his own autobiographical words Mark Twain, author
- Image from Wikipedia
I am a Mugwump! What is a mugwump? Well you need to let historical records be your guide, not modern interpretation. If you use Wikipedia, where I got the image I use in this piece, you would come to the conclusion it was a bunch of Republicans who betrayed their party to vote for a democratic candidate. In much of the modern literature, you will see a similar characterization. You need to go back and read contemporaneous descriptions.
Why do I think we need more mugwumps today? Perhaps, it is the constant cry for political purity I am reacting to. I find myself, more and more, irritated by those seeking their political solace in the wrapping of party purity. Party purity is always a much easier choice – isn’t it? Simply swallow the syrup and be content with your choice. If you do that little thing, we will assure you that you will get exactly what we, I mean you want. No worries! We will take care of it all. Don’t pay any attention to the man behind the curtain.
This has worked so well for both parties throughout my lifetime, most people can’t contemplate any other way. The divisions in ideology have gotten progressively further and further apart! There is one problem – it’s never worked for me!
Mugwump Revelation #1
I voted for Jerry Brown… There I said it, although I have said it before as well. I voted for Jerry, because I have come to know him personally and professionally and his actions undermined the convenient image I allowed to be crafted by the media of “Governor Moonbeam” many years before. I found him refreshingly pragmatic, dedicated, committed to concepts much larger than himself and highly principled. Most importantly, I learned I could trust that he would do as I expected – not always as I want. That is for me, and should be for all of us, highly prized in a politician.
Mugwump Revelation #2
I consider Don Perata (the President Pro Tempore emeritus of the California Senate) a good friend. If I had been a resident of Oakland, I would have voted for him as well – for the same reasons. I have found him to be highly dedicated, pragmatic and committed to issues bigger than himself as well. Like Jerry, he is – from my viewpoint- predictable and willing to listen and assimilate contra-posing viewpoints.
So, I have been damned and ridiculed by some for these positions, but I feel I am a stronger man for it and more importantly I feel we are a stronger California and country as well. I am fortunate that I was raised to have good self esteem, and a strong personality so I don’t have a problem saying scr– them to those who have attacked me on this front. Like Twain, I will pick who I feel is the best person to fulfill the task in front of them, regardless of party and opposing ideology.
Sure there are some ideological positions that are selection points but they are not all inclusive. Now, I simply have become able to look deeper at the candidate and find out where we agree and focus there as opposed to vilifying where we disagree.
I shout – I am a mugwump – and I am proud!
More should be mugwumps, in my opinion. If we had more mugwumps we may have less, and more effective government because ideological pandering would no longer be profitable.
So, in the end I ask you: Consider a mugwump! Perhaps you have an inner mugwump yearning to be free!
9 Responses
Wow, wonderful blog layout! How long have you ever been blogging for? you made running a blog look easy. The total look of your website is fantastic, as smartly as the content! Sorry for poor English I am stopping in from Brazil!
I have been wareing a Mugwump hat for a year or so and have not recruted any other indepentents, eventhough they seem to agree with the need to have more influence on the party platforms. We are the deciding factor in who is elected (assuming that we are the swing voters) therfore should have more influence on how they govern. Is it possible that independents are not organnizeable? ie GDI, JVL
Incredible points. Sound arguments. Keep up the good work.
as a mugwump i was suprised by your support of mitt romney. i know you are concerned about the federal reserve. it is neither federal nor is there a reserve. it is a private bank that also prints our public money. i know that mr obama is close to wall street bankers but mr romney is even closer and more likely to give in to the federal reserve and the banking greed. how did your mugwumpery lead you to mr romney?
Mr Romney is not a fan if the fed or of policies like quantitative easing.
interesting, sounds more like ron paul. maybe he should have talked more about that. funny the big money seemed to like him even though he was against the biggest bank. yes i have a lot to learn
Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed!
Very helpful information particularly the last part 🙂 I care
for such information a lot. I was seeking this particular info for a very long time.
Thank you and good luck.